Murphy

We had a difference of opinion on the grade of this climb and its relative difficulty compared to

Thwarted

to the right, so we just called them both 9+.  You decide!   Morning sun.   Either stick clip and pull a move off the ground or start on the route to the right (with an obvious low bolt in direcltly  a cobble) and traverse left to to get the first bolt of

Murphy

.

Just left of the very blunt arete, and right of the Lair cave.   The first bolt is pretty high and must be stick clipped or you can start on the low bolt of the route to the right and traverse in.

6? Stainless bolts, chains with steel biners